The Organ Forum

Discussion forums for the King of Instruments
Welcome to The Organ Forum Sign in | Join | Help
in Search


new pipe organ in the french style

Last post 07-23-2008, 6:31 AM by sesquialtera16. 6 replies.
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  •  07-21-2008, 5:46 AM 58730

    new pipe organ in the french style

  •  07-21-2008, 12:22 PM 58763 in reply to 58730

    Re: new pipe organ in the french style

    It looks like a very nice instrument, but I note that there is a lot of borrowing/extension.  In reality, if my count is correct, there are only 22 ranks in that organ, though several have extensions:  6 in the Grande Orgue; 10 in the Recit Expressif; none in the Positif (all borrowed); and 6 in the Pedale.  That, of course, is not necessarily a bad thing, but it does make the Stop List look a lot more impressive than is reality.  I'm not enough of an organist to know if that scheme of rank usage is a good one--I'll leave that determination to experts such as Soubasse32 and others here.  (Note:  I only counted the Fourniture II-IV as 2 ranks.)

    David

  •  07-21-2008, 12:55 PM 58766 in reply to 58763

    Re: new pipe organ in the french style

    What a delightful little organ and what a lovely console!  They probably did this for well under $500,000.  If the same stops were all straight, the cost could have been $1 million.  And this may not a be a large church.

    My only caveat is that such designs should come with a laminated chart that tells the organist(s) exactly how the stops are borrowed and distributed.  Then the instrument may be used to maximum versatile effect without accidentally overdoing it.

  •  07-22-2008, 9:46 AM 58836 in reply to 58766

    Re: new pipe organ in the french style

    MenchenStimme:

    My only caveat is that such designs should come with a laminate chart that tells the organist(s) exactly how the stops are borrowed and distributed.  Then the instrument may be used to maximum versatile effect without accidentally overdoing it.

    Amen! I cannot even describe how many instruments I have played, and to my dismay, have stumbled upon pitch drop-out from unification!

    I rather like the neat little organ Gluck put in the chapel at First Pres. in New York. It has a lot of character (amidst the unification Surprise).

    Violoncelle
     


    Do you Has what it takes to be an Organist?
  •  07-22-2008, 1:56 PM 58849 in reply to 58730

    Re: new pipe organ in the french style

    Love the look of that organ.  All that nice wood. No plastic in sight! Big Smile

    2m Viscount Opera Organ
  •  07-23-2008, 6:27 AM 58888 in reply to 58766

    Re: new pipe organ in the french style

    MenchenStimme:

    What a delightful little organ and what a lovely console!  They probably did this for well under $500,000.  If the same stops were all straight, the cost could have been $1 million.  And this may not a be a large church.

    My only caveat is that such designs should come with a laminated chart that tells the organist(s) exactly how the stops are borrowed and distributed.  Then the instrument may be used to maximum versatile effect without accidentally overdoing it.

    Under $500,000?  You couldn't even buy a Rubenstein R-371 grand piano for that amount.


    I am NOT a PC programmer. I program on Mainframe computers!

    Non omnes qui habemt citharam sunt citharoedi
  •  07-23-2008, 6:31 AM 58889 in reply to 58888

    Re: new pipe organ in the french style

    when u r a stellar figure in the organ mafia then u can afford a discount to put a feather in ur cap and say u sold an organ to the rockfellers
View as RSS news feed in XML


Powered by Community Server (Personal Edition), by Telligent Systems